MCCA® 2010 Fortune 1000 Minority General Counsel Survey


Frank R. Jimenez, ITT Corporation
Vice President and General Counsel

Nicole Jones, Lincoln Financial Group
Senior Vice President and General Counsel

Samrat Khichi, Catalent Pharma Solutions
Senior Vice President and General Counsel
Chief Compliance Officer and Secretary

The U.S. economy is stumbling along with persistent job losses and dire warnings of a double-dip recession, but the big story for the 2010 class of the Fortune 500 is the stunning 335% increase in earnings— a jump of $301 billion over the previous year. Perhaps more surprising is that this massive earnings increase occurred despite a sharp fall in revenues. Sales by Fortune 500 companies fell 8.7% to $9.8 trillion, the biggest decline since the early 1980s1. But while corporate cost-cutting dictated job losses at many Fortune 500 firms, for the most part, minority general counsel managed to avoid the pain.

As the gross domestic product shrank by around 6% in 2008 and early 2009, and sales decreased alarmingly, companies responded by furiously slashing costs. Since about two-thirds of company costs come from labor, that meant job losses. Fortune 500 companies cut 821,000 jobs in 2009, a 3.2% reduction in payroll, which is the biggest reduction of its kind in the history of the list. With only modest increases in wages for 2009, the labor costs for American companies fell by 4.6%, the biggest drop in postwar history. Companies maintained this iron grip on costs to offset overall revenue shortfalls as economic growth finally returned late last year, leading to the massive increase in profits. Increased sales and falling unit labor costs resulted in healthy bottom lines in the Fortune 500.2

With consumers searching for bargains and shunning discretionary purchases, electronics retailers and auto-parts suppliers were punished, but budget-conscious Walmart was rewarded for its low prices with a 7% surge in earnings to $14.3 billion. Overall, 2009 was a good year for Fortune 500 companies selling products consumers considered essential, but a bad year for those selling items customers merely wanted to have.3

Forty-three companies on the 2010 Fortune 500 list employed minorities as general counsel (8.6 percent), an increase of two over the previous year and up six from 2008. Of those 45 minority general counsel, 25 are African Americans, 11 are Asian Americans and seven are Hispanic Americans. Overall, the number of African American general counsel in the Fortune 500 is down one from 2009, but Hispanics have increased their number by two.

Increasingly, women of color are also taking the lead of Fortune 500 legal departments. In 2008 and 2009 eight women of color held the position of general counsel, but that number increased to 11 on the 2010 list. Of those 12 women, seven are African Americans, three are Hispanic Americans, and one is Asian American. Compared to 2009, African American women increased their number by two and Hispanic American women increased their number by one.

At the Fortune 250 level, 28 companies are represented by a minority general counsel, an increase of one over 2009. Fifteen of these are African Americans, six are Hispanic American, and another six are Asian American.

As evidence of the progress made, some of the most famous companies in the United States have legal departments run by persons of color. Among them are: Dell (Lawrence Tu), United Parcel Service (Teri Plummer-McClure), Sears Holdings (William Harker), PepsiCo (Larry Thompson), Google (David Drummond), McDonald’s (Gloria Santona), Xerox (Don Liu), General Mills (Roderick A. Palmore), Sara Lee (Brett Hart), Avon Products (Kim Rucker), Starbucks (Paula Boggs), Dole Food (Michael Carter), Avis Budget Group (Michael K. Tucker), and Western Union (Martin J. Wong).

Of the 2010 Fortune 500 companies with chief legal officers of color, 13 had revenues of at least $20 billion, a drop of 3 from 2009. Fourteen companies on the list had revenues between $10 billion and $20 billion, thirteen companies had revenues between $5 billion and $10 billion, and five companies had revenues under $5 billion. Of the 45 Fortune 500 companies with minority general counsel, only six were not profitable in 2010.

MCCA 2010 Fortune 500 Minority General Counsel

MCCA 2010 Fortune 501-1000 Minority General Counsel

Some of the best performing companies on the 2010 Fortune 500 list are represented by minority general counsel. For example, five of the most profitable companies in America were Bristol-Myers Squibb (GC Sandra Leung), Google (GC David Drummond), Liberty Media (GC Charles Tanabe), PepsiCo (GC Larry Thompson), and McDonald’s (GC Gloria Santona).

Among the 20 fastest-growing companies on the Fortune 500, persons of color run the legal departments of four, including William Harker at Sears Holdings, John Chou at Amerisource Bergen, Don Liu at Xerox, and Douglas Williams at Limited Brands. Bristol-Myers Squibb and Google also made the list of fastest growing companies on the 2010 Fortune 500.

Liberty Media, with GC Charles Tanabe, offered the most return on revenues of any company in the 2010 Fortune 500 list and Bristol-Myers Squibb (GC Sandra Leung) offered the second highest return on revenue. Google (GC David Drummond) made the top 10 list in return on revenue and McDonald’s (GC Gloria Santona), Spectra Energy (GC Reginald Hedgebeth), and Western Union (GC Martin J. Wong) were also high on that list. For total return to shareholders, no company in the Fortune 500 performed better in 2009 than Avis Budget Group, where Michael K. Tucker is general counsel. ArvinMeritor (GC Vernon Baker) and Starbucks (GC Paula Boggs) were also exceptional performers.

Fortune 500 general counsel of color are a geographically diverse group. California is home to 10 minority general counsel-led companies, tops on the list and an increase of one from 2009. Moving into second place this year is Illinois, home to seven companies on the list. New York falls from second to third with six companies employing minority general counsel on the Fortune 500. States such as Texas, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Florida, and Colorado were also represented by multiple companies with minority chief legal officers.

MCCA List of Minority General Counsel at Fortune 500 Companies
MCCA List of Minority General Counsel at Fortune 500 Companies (continued)

Fortune 500 Departures and Arrivals
There were some losses on this year’s list, with some Fortune 500 companies replacing a general counsel of color with a white GC. Chevron [3 overall] replaced African American Charles James with Hewitt Pate, and Proctor & Gamble [22] replaced African American Steven Jemison with Deborah Platt Majoras. In addition, MetLife [51] replaced African American James Lipscomb with Nicholas D. Latrenta, and Wesco International [448] replaced African American male Leslie J. Parrette Jr. with Diane Lazzaris.

Newcomers to the Fortune 500 list of minority chief legal officers include African Americans Michael K. Tucker of Avis Budget Group [409 overall], who replaced a white female in May 2010, and Keith Williamson, who runs the legal department of Centene, which moved from 609 last year to 486 on this year’s list.

Fortune 501-1000
The number of chief legal officers of color in the Fortune 10004 bounced back after a decline in 2009. The 2010 Fortune 1000 includes 27 companies with minority general counsel, an increase of three over the previous year. Of the 26, 11 are African Americans, eight are Asian Americans, six are Hispanic Americans and one is a Pacific Islander, who is grouped as an Asian American. That represents an increase of one each for African Americans, Asians and Hispanic Americans. Six of the 27 general counsel of color are women, including four African Americans, one Asian American and one Hispanic American.

With five, California is once again home to the highest number of general counsels of color at Fortune 1000 companies. New Jersey is home to four companies on the list and the rest are spread fairly evenly around the country, with New York, Florida, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Texas among the states with multiple companies employing minority general counsel. The list also includes a company from Puerto Rico and one from Washington, D.C.

Fortune 1000 Newcomers
Newcomers to the Fortune 1000 include Paul Chung of Targa Resources (505 overall), Ram Wertheim of MBIA (655), Kellye Walker of American Water Works (734), Roberto Garcia of Triple-S Management (838), Samrat Khichi of Catalent Pharma Solutions (948), Alberto de Cardenas of Mas Tec (968), and A.B. Cruz of Scripps Networks Interactive (992). African American Gregory Nixon of DynCorp International (627) is another new- comer to the Fortune 1000, having replaced a white male as general counsel of his company.

MCCA List of Minority General Counsel at Fortune 500 Companies

Continued Growth
The stringent cost-cutting of 2010 imposed hardships on many workers, but talented minority lawyers continued to expand their presence at the reins of many of the nation’s most important and profitable corporate legal departments. Their contributions are an important part of the success of their companies in 2009 and beyond. That future should be bright indeed, for though only 9% of all Fortune 500 companies are represented by minority general counsel (up from 8.6% the year before), 20% of the fastest-growing companies have persons of color running their legal department. Some of the brightest stars of the 2010 Fortune 500 were Liberty Media, Bristol-Myers Squibb, and Google, each with a minority general counsel. And while the small number of minority women in last year’s list was correctly described as a “disappointment,” the 33% increase in one year (from 8 to 12) is encouraging. If today’s success is indicative of progress tomorrow, the future should be bright for minority general counsel in the Fortune 500. DB

1 Shawn Tully, Fortune 500: Profits bounce back, Fortune, April 15, 2010, available at (visited June 18, 2010).

2 Id.

3 Id.

In this article, the term "Fortune 1000" refers to companies ranked among Fortune's 501-1000 companies.

From the September/October 2010 issue of  Diversity & The Bar®

General Counsel Summit

May 6 - 9, 2015 - General Counsel Summit (formerly the General Counsel Invitational)

Latest News

  • Hot Jobs - March 2015
    Summary: MCCA to sends out an email blast of Hot Job announcements to our network on the last Friday of every month. Check out the latest job postings.
  • MCCA Announces Annual Employer of Choice Award Honorees
    Summary: MCCA announced today the five recipients of the 2015 Employer of Choice Awards, who will be honored during the 2015 Diversity Gala on June 30th at the John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts in Washington, D.C.
  • Lawyers of Color's Annual Power List
    Summary: MCCA President and CEO Joseph K. West was named to the Lawyers of Color’s Annual Power List. The Annual Power List highlights the nation’s most influential minority attorneys and non-minority diversity advocates

More News

Fast Facts

Americans aged 25-34 have the second highest rate of bankruptcy (just after those aged 35 to 44), indicating that Gen-Xers were more likely to file for bankruptcy than were young baby boomers at the same age.
Source: "Generation Broke: The Growth of Debt among Young Americans."
The average young-adult household spends almost one quarter of every dollar earned on debt payments.
Source: "Generation Broke: The Growth of Debt among Young Americans."
The annual unemployment rate in 2012 for Management, Professionals, and Related Occupations was 4.1%.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics
Nearly two-thirds of the 5.4 million legal immigrants from Mexico who are eligible to become citizens of the US have not yet taken that step. Their naturalization rate-36%-is only half that of legal immigrants from all other countries combined.
Source: Pew Research Center
The overall U.S. birth rate declined 8% from 2007 to 2010. The birth rate for U.S.-born women decreased 6% during these years, but the birth rate for foreign-born women plunged 14%-more than it had declined over the entire 1990-2007 period.1 The birth rate for Mexican immigrant women fell even more, by 23%.
Source: Pew Research Center
Three-quarters of retirees said they worked longer than they would have otherwise to maintain access to their employer healthcare plan. The Affordable Care Act does include provisions aimed at reining in prices by limiting the amount insurers can charge older Americans to 3 times what they charge younger subscribers.
Source: The Washington Post
Only four in ten third-graders in the District of Columbia can read proficiently, and only about four out of ten young adults in the District have a full-time job.
Source: Raise D.C.
In 1779, before his time as president, Thomas Jefferson proposed a law to castrate gay men and to destroy the nose cartilage of gay women.
Source: Washington Lawyer
Pennsylvania was the first state to repeal the death penalty for sodomy in 1786.
Source: Washington Lawyer
In 1924 the Society for Human Rights in Chicago became the country's first gay rights organization. Other organizations such as the Mattachine Society and the daughters of Bilitis, were formed decades later.
Source: Washington Lawyer
In 1962 Illinois became the first state to decriminalize homosexual acts done in private between consenting adults.
Source: Washington Lawyer
The nationalities with the highest rates of nationalization in the US - about75% - are Vietnamese, Russian, Filipino, Korean, Laotian, and Cuban.
Source: The Pew Research Center
To become a citizen of the US, a legal permanent resident must be at least 18 years; have lived in the US continuously for 5 years; be able to speak, read, write, and understand basic English; pass a background check; demonstrate knowledge of US history and government; swear allegiance to the US; and pay the $680 application fee.
Source: The Washington Post
The Bridgeport-Stamford-Norwalk, Conn., metropolitan area, near New York City, had the highest percentage (17.9%) of households with at least $191,469 in income. At the other end of the spectrum are two metro areas named Danville -- in Virginia and Illinois -- each with 1.1% of households having such high income.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau
National Women's History Month dates back to March 8, 1857, when women in NYC factories staged a protest over working conditions. International Women's Day was first observed in 1909, but it wasn't until 1981 that Congress established National Women's History Week, celebrated the 2nd week of March. In 1987, the week was expanded to a month.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau
Americans aged 25-34 have the second highest rate of bankruptcy (just after those aged 35 to 44), indicating that Gen-Xers were more likely to file for bankruptcy than were young baby boomers at the same age.
Source: "Generation Broke: The Growth of Debt among Young Americans."
The average young-adult household spends almost one quarter of every dollar earned on debt payments.
Source: "Generation Broke: The Growth of Debt among Young Americans."
The annual unemployment rate in 2012 for Management, Professionals, and Related Occupations was 4.1%.
Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics
MicrosoftMorgan Lewis MCAAWal-Mart Womble Carlyle